Headline: Court Dismisses Lawsuit Alleging Misleading Burger Sizes Against Wendy’s and McDonald’s

Wendy and McDonald: Court Dismisses Lawsuit Alleging Misleading Burger Sizes Against Wendy’s and McDonald’s | Enterprise Wired

Share Post:

LinkedIn
Twitter
Facebook
Reddit

In a recent ruling, a federal judge in Brooklyn has dismissed a lawsuit against fast-food giants Wendy and McDonald, which accused the companies of exaggerating the size of their burgers in advertisements.

The Decision

In a comprehensive 19-page decision delivered on Saturday, Judge Hector Gonzalez of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York determined that there was no evidence to suggest that the popular fast-food chains delivered smaller burgers than advertised, and therefore, had not misled customers.

The lawsuit, filed by Justin Chimienti of New York in 2022, alleged that Wendy and McDonald engaged in deceptive advertising practices by presenting burgers in a way that differed significantly from what customers received. Chimienti claimed that the size of the burgers, particularly Wendy’s Bourbon Bacon Cheeseburger and McDonald’s Big Mac, were grossly overstated in advertisements.

However, Judge Gonzalez pointed out that there was uncertainty regarding whether the plaintiff had even seen the specific ads he cited as examples in his complaint. The ruling emphasized that the companies’ use of visually appealing images to showcase their products was a common marketing strategy, and Wendy and McDonald were no exception.

Wendy and McDonald sued over burger sizes

Chimienti’s Complaint

Chimienti’s complaint asserted that the companies utilized undercooked beef patties in their advertising to compensate for the expected shrinkage of meat during the cooking process. The lawsuit featured cropped photos of burgers from ads compared to images shared on social media by customers, alleging a significant disparity.

Both McDonald’s, headquartered in Chicago, and Wendy’s, based in Dublin, Ohio, have not immediately responded to requests for comment. The plaintiff’s lawyers also remained silent on the recent development.

Other Legal Actions

This lawsuit is among several recent legal actions targeting fast-food chains for alleged misrepresentation in their advertising. In August, a federal judge in Miami refused to dismiss a class-action lawsuit against Burger King, claiming the overstatement of meat content in the Whopper burger. Additionally, Taco Bell faces a separate lawsuit accusing the chain of overstating the amount of beans and meat in some menu items, including the Mexican Pizza and Crunchwrap Supreme.

While the dismissed lawsuit sought unspecified monetary damages, it serves as a reminder of the ongoing scrutiny that major fast-food companies face over the accuracy of their advertising claims. The ruling underscores the importance of clear evidence in such cases, indicating that visual marketing practices, even if deemed exaggerated, may not necessarily translate to intentional deception.

Subscribe

RELATED ARTICLES

OpenAI Partially Prevails as Judge Dismisses Copyright Lawsuits by Silverman and Tremblay

OpenAI Partially Prevails as Judge Dismisses Copyright Lawsuits by Silverman and Tremblay

Federal Judge Rules on OpenAI’s Use of Authors’ Works in Training AI Model In a significant development, two copyright infringement…
FTC Investigates Drug Supply Chain: Focus on Middlemen Amid Generic Drug Shortages

FTC Investigates Drug Supply Chain: Focus on Middlemen Amid Generic Drug Shortages

Source- PYMNTS.com Federal Trade Commission and HHS Seek Solutions for Ongoing Drug Shortages In response to the persistent shortages of…
Cisco Announces Workforce Reduction Amid Industry Downturn

Cisco Announces Workforce Reduction Amid Industry Downturn

Source- BNN Breaking Tech Giant to Cut 5% of Workforce, Eliminating 4,250 Jobs In a move to streamline operations amidst…
Lyft CEO Takes Responsibility for Earnings Error, Stock Soars

Lyft CEO Takes Responsibility for Earnings Error, Stock Soars

Major Error Causes Stock Surge and Subsequent Correction Lyft CEO David Risher has acknowledged responsibility for a significant error in…